Italian Chef, but onions in the Carbonara? I'm starting this fight for you
qponx
2026-01-23
Expatriate in Kelapa Gading serves up a cozy Italian vibe with some surprising twists. While the Pistachio Cream Fettuccine is hailed as an unforgettable, must-try dish, the Carbonara might shock purists with its inclusion of onions. This review breaks down the hits and misses, from inconsistent pizza to a very loud weekend live band. Discover tips on when to visit for a quiet chat and how to snag the best value with their Omakase sets.
Honestly, every time I hear"an authentic restaurant run by an Italian," my DNA just lights up. This time at Expatriate in Kelapa Gading, the head chef, Carmine, is indeed Italian[1], and the restaurant's vibe is incredibly cozy. Dim lighting with a retro feel, perfect for a nongkrong session. But when I sat down, opened the menu, and saw Carbonara, my heart sank a little... I had a feeling something was about to go wrong on this visit.
So, is this a gem worth visiting again and again, or a huge"photo scam"? Let's break it down.
First, let's talk about what absolutely blew my mind! Pistachio Cream Fettuccine (Fettuccine Cream di Pistachi)[2], you guys have to try it! The pistachio sauce is unbelievably rich, every single strand of handmade pasta is coated in it, a perfect blend of sweet and savory with a silky texture, truly Mantap in one bite! No exaggeration, this is definitely one of the best pasta dishes I've had in Jakarta, and I'd come back just for this!
Then, the main event, that controversial Carbonara[3]. How should I put this... Anjay! It's definitely very cheesy, but... it actually has onions in it! And the overall flavor is on the sweeter side. If you're a purist seeking the traditional Roman recipe (only egg yolks, Pecorino cheese, and Guanciale), you might want to flip the table on the spot. But if you think of it as a"localized, modified creamy bacon pasta," the taste is actually... not bad? 🤷♀️
Their Pizza[4] is also a hit-or-miss affair. A friend said it's the best in North Jakarta, with a thin and crispy crust. But the one I had this time, I felt the crust was a bit chewy, and the flavor was just unremarkable. Maybe it depends on your luck and the chef's mood that day.
Let's be real. The biggest pitfall of this place is the live band[5] on weekends. It creates a vibe, but the volume is so loud you basically have to shout to talk to the friend across from you. Friends who want to have a proper conversation should just stay away. Also, the service is in a Schrödinger-like state. Sometimes it's warm and attentive, other times you wait forever for your food, and they might even bring the wrong dish, which kind of ruins the experience.
TL;DR & Guide to Avoiding Pitfalls 📝
Don't order à la carte. If you want to try a variety, go straight for their Omakase set[6]! For example, the 188k three-course set lets you taste the chef's surprise pairings and is amazing value for money. They also often have buy-one-get-one pizza deals or credit card discounts, so you can ask before you go.
If you want to chat, definitely don't go on a weekend night[7]! Unless you want a Jakarta Live House experience. Go on a weekday evening to sit quietly and chill, that's the best vibe.
Friends who want to try something new and aren't too hung up on the word"authentic," or those who are just going for that pistachio pasta, should give it a try. Hardcore enthusiasts seeking the ultimate traditional Italian flavor should consider with caution.
Remember to book in advance[8], it gets full easily during meal times. They also have a vegetarian menu and Shisha[9], so there are quite a few options.
- How to get the best deal?
- When to go?
- Who is this recommended for?
- Other Tips:
- Jakarta's rare pistachio cream pasta! Rich sauce, handmade noodles, sweet-savory bliss. Top-tier! [1]
- Just 188k for a chef's surprise 3-course Omakase set! Amazing value, you'll want to rush there! [2]
- Prepare for a "localized" Carbonara! Rich cheese, sweet onion notes. How "unauthentic" can it get? [3]
Similar Articles
Google's 4.9 stars: Faked? This Jakarta hotpot spot is something else.
Skeptical about a 4.9-star Google rating? This review dives into Jakarta's Kungfu Hotpot and confirms it’s the real deal. The star is the authentic Herbal Pork Stomach and Chicken soup, a rich, MSG-free broth that’s soul-stirring. Don’t miss the bouncy handmade pork balls and unique fish noodles. While a bit pricey, the article shares essential tips on booking, group dining for better value, scoring discounts, and even finding the free self-serve ice cream.
100k+ per person & a battle for seats. Is this Gading French patisserie really worth it?
This popular French patisserie in Kelapa Gading is always packed, but is it worth the hype and the 100k+ price tag? The article explores their legendary Pistachio Tiramisu and creative Choux that have dessert lovers raving. While the taste is top-notch, get a heads-up on the steep prices, tiny space, and hit-or-miss service. Find out if the viral spot is right for you and get honest tips before you brave the crowds for these decadent treats.
Jakarta BBQ Warning! Did the staff at this Gyu-Kaku branch go on strike?
Thinking of visiting Gyu-Kaku in Jakarta? You might want to read this first! This review exposes a disastrous dining experience at the MKG branch, calling out everything from inattentive service and low-quality meat to faulty equipment. Despite the overall letdown, there was one surprising star: a divine milk pudding. Discover why you should avoid this specific location unless you're only going for the dessert, and learn which other branches are recommended for a much better Japanese BBQ experience.
A "God-Tier" Spot in North Jakarta? The vibe is Mantap, but the service and food made me go Anjay.
Thinking of visiting Pabbo & Co in North Jakarta? This trendy spot wins big on atmosphere with its spacious vibe, live music, and budget-friendly prices, making it a go-to for young crowds. But hold on—the experience isn't all perfect. This review dives into the major letdowns of its poor food and frustrating service. It's a classic case of "all vibe, no substance." Find out if the great atmosphere is enough to make it worth your while.