This Makassar Gelato is God-tier! But I almost went Anjay at the cashier.
qponx
2026-03-06
Discover WHIMSEY GELATO, a Makassar spot serving up "god-tier" gelato with an incredibly silky texture and authentic flavors. The article highlights must-try options like rich Pistachio and refreshing Black Tea Yuzu. But there's a catch! This review gives a crucial heads-up on surprise extra charges for premium flavors and cones that the staff might not mention. Get the scoop on how to enjoy this delicious treat without the unexpected hit to your wallet.
In Makassar, just finished some ice cream, and my feelings are a bit complicated…
This place, WHIMSEY GELATO, has a 4.9 rating on Google[1], and my lokal friends hyped it up like crazy, calling it "the best Gelato in Makassar"[2]. I originally went to check it out with an "is it really that good?" attitude, and the result... well, the taste is truly Mantap! But there's a catch, which I'll get to later.
The texture is god-tier, no arguments accepted
Let's talk about the good stuff first, otherwise it wouldn't be fair to the calories I consumed. The shop isn't big and there aren't many seats, but the decor is quite cute, with a bit of a Balinese streetside shop chill vibe[3]. It's clean and comfortable, perfect for coming with friends to Nongkrong for an afternoon.
The main point is the ice cream itself! The texture is absolutely amazing, super silky and smooth (super lembut), and the sweetness is just right. You can eat a whole one without feeling sick of it[4]. You can tell it's made with real ingredients, without any weird artificial flavors. I heard they don't even add coloring, so it's safe for kids to eat too[5].
I went for a few of their signature flavors:
- Pistachio (Pistachio): A signature must-order[6], the flavor is super rich, a nut lover's dream come true!
- Black Tea Yuzu (Black Tea Yuzu): This combination is such a surprise! The slight bitterness of the tea and the refreshing tartness of the yuzu are perfectly balanced, full marks for complexity[7], so sophisticated!
- 70% Dark Chocolate (Dark Chocolate): My friend ordered this, and I snagged a bite. It's that authentic, slightly bitter dark chocolate[8] that chocolate lovers will absolutely adore.
- Matcha (Matcha): Also very authentic, not that overly sweet matcha flavor. You can taste the true flavor of the tea[9].
But! I was dumbfounded when it was time to pay…
Okay, enough with the praise, it's time to complain. The taste is really good, but the service experience is a bit hard to describe. I only found out when I was paying that my pistachio flavor and the switch to a cone both had extra charges! One was an extra 12k, the other an extra 6k.
The key thing is, the staff didn't mention it at all from start to finish[10]! Even though it wasn't a lot of money, it just felt really bad, like I was set up (dijebak), Anjay! My good mood was instantly ruined. I saw in the reviews that I'm not the only one who's experienced this. This is something they really need to improve!
Guide to Avoiding Pitfalls & TL;DR Strategy
So, for the girls who want to go, here's a summary in plain English:
Overall, the taste is definitely top-tier in Makassar and worth a try. But as for the customer experience... I hope the shop can be more mindful! For the girls who have been, have you experienced the same thing? Let's chat in the comments! 👇
- 1. Ask about the price first! Before ordering, make sure to ask clearly which special flavors (like pistachio) or choosing a cone cost extra. Don't be a sucker like me.
- 2. Try samples first! You can ask the staff for a tester to try the flavors. I heard you can try 2-4 flavors before deciding[11], so don't be shy!
- 3. Go during off-peak hours! The shop is small with limited seating[12], so if you want to sit down, take your time with photos, and chat, it's best to avoid mealtimes and weekend peaks.
- The Pistachio Gelato is intensely rich—a dream for nut lovers! A signature must-order you can't miss [1]
- Black Tea Yuzu is a surprise hit, perfectly balancing the tea's bitterness with tart yuzu. So complex and delicious! [2]
- Google 4.9 stars [3]! Locals rave it's Makassar's best Gelato, with a super chill, Balinese roadside vibe [4]
Similar Articles
A 2-hour wait for an 11k coffee?! Investigating this Makassar cafe.
Is a coffee really worth a two-hour wait? This article investigates a wildly popular Makassar cafe where drinks cost as little as 11k IDR. Discover the secret behind the long queues at Yotta, which boasts a fantastic, work-friendly atmosphere with stable WiFi and ample power outlets, making it a haven for students and digital nomads. Find out which drinks are worth the hype and get exclusive tips to beat the crowds and save some cash.
Come to Makassar just for this? East Indonesia's biggest mall—watch this before you decide.
Thinking about visiting Trans Studio Mall, East Indonesia's biggest shopping center? This article gives you the real scoop. Discover its massive size, complete brand selection, and an exciting indoor theme park perfect for families. But be warned! It also reveals the downsides, like disastrous weekend crowds and tricky parking payment systems. Get all the essential tips, from scoring discounts to finding secret free seats, to decide if it's worth the trip and how to survive your visit.
4.6 stars on Google, but why is the floor an oily skating rink?
This highly-rated Padang restaurant is a true paradox. While the floors are notoriously slippery and hygiene can be questionable, the authentic food is an absolute showstopper. This guide reveals the must-order dishes, like the incredibly tender Ayam Pop and savory Sate Padang, that make it all worthwhile. Discover the essential tips for navigating the pitfalls—from service quirks to checking your bill—to enjoy a truly memorable meal that’s packed with flavor.
Don't Be Fooled by the 4.9 Google Rating! A Brutally Honest Review of Makassar's Legendary Retro Spot.
Thinking of visiting Makassar's highly-rated Kedai Lawas? This honest review looks past the 4.9-star hype. While the photogenic 80s retro vibe and incredible Nasi Daging Cabe Ijo are major wins, it's not all perfect. Learn about the inconsistent service, slow food, and practical pitfalls like limited parking and a lack of power outlets. Discover if the nostalgic atmosphere and standout dishes are worth the potential hassle before you visit this legendary spot.