This 4.8-star legendary Makassar spot on Google: Is it really flawless?
qponx
2026-03-06
Curious about a legendary Makassar cafe with a near-perfect 4.8-star rating? This spot mostly lives up to the hype with its incredible Beef Stroganoff and handmade ice cream that you can sample for free. But it's not flawless. This honest review reveals the downsides, like small portions and a noisy atmosphere, while giving you the inside scoop on what makes it a gem and how to have the best experience on your visit.
Here in Makassar, I came across this cafe with 1700+ Google reviews and a high rating of 4.8, and my curiosity was piqued! 🧐
Honestly, I usually approach these highly-rated places with a mix of anticipation and skepticism. After all, it's not uncommon for overhyped, influencer-filtered spots to be a letdown, right? But this time… I think I've really found a gem.
Great Vibe, But Beware of "Little Devils"
The place isn't big, but the decor is quite comfortable, and the music taste is on point—not that deafening, tacky stuff. The whole vibe is very cozy, definitely an ideal spot to Nongkrong with the girls. 👌
I was immediately drawn to the ice cream counter upon entering; it was so colorful and therapeutic to look at. Their handmade ice cream is a specialty, and you can try three flavors for free[1] first—what a way to win people over! I tried the caramel Irish coffee flavor, which has alcohol in it. It wasn't cloyingly sweet, and the flavor was incredibly rich. A small cup is only 26k Indonesian Rupiah[2], Mantap!
For my main course, I went straight for the most hyped dish: the Beef Stroganoff[3]. Oh my god, I have to rave about this! The beef was stewed until it was tender and flavorful, the sauce was perfectly balanced, and it was served with creamy mashed potatoes and crisp vegetables. Every bite was a delight. The restaurant also officially recommends the Nasi Lidah Sambal Ijo[4] (Ox Tongue Rice with Green Chili Sambal). The picture alone made my mouth water—I'll definitely have to try it next time!
Some Real Talk: It's Not All Perfect
Okay, enough with the praise, let's get real. This place isn't without its flaws.
First off, that Beef Stroganoff I couldn't get enough of—the beef portion was honestly a bit stingy…[5] For a meat lover, it's definitely not enough!
Secondly, the environment. While it's comfortable, if you're looking for a quiet place to work or have a deep conversation, I'd advise you to think twice. When we were there, a few families with kids were around, and the children were running everywhere, instantly turning the place into a family fun park. It got a bit Anjay noisy…[6] My friend's chicken salad was also a bit of a miss; he said the chicken was a little dry and tough[7].
My Honest-to-Goodness Guide 📝
Alright, your class rep has summarized it all, so get your little notebooks ready:
- Must-Order List ✅:
- Beef Stroganoff[8]: Order it without a second thought! If you don't like it, you can come and find me.
- Handmade Ice Cream[9]: A blessing for the indecisive—try before you buy.
- Heads-Up on What to Avoid 💣:
- The Chicken Chopped Salad[10] and the waffles[11] get mixed reviews, so maybe peek at what the next table is having before you order.
- For my fellow "socially anxious" friends who need a quiet environment, I recommend avoiding weekends or peak meal times. Otherwise, the noise from the rowdy kids might make you question all your life decisions[12].
- Pro Tips ✨:
- If you're with a big group, you can book their VIP room[13] directly. It's perfect for a birthday party or a small gathering.
- Remember to follow their IG. They sometimes post holiday discounts[14], and every little bit saved helps
- 4.8-star cafe! Get free samples of 3 ice cream flavors[1]. The rich Caramel Irish Coffee is a steal at just 26k IDR![2]
- Don't miss the Beef Stroganoff[3]! Fall-apart tender beef, perfect sauce, with mash & veggies. Blame me if you don't love it!
- Planning a small gathering? Book a VIP room[4]! Follow their IG for holiday discounts[5] and save some cash.
Similar Articles
No menu, cash only. How is this Makassar fried chicken spot so viral?
Discover the secret behind a viral Makassar fried chicken joint that operates with no menu and a cash-only policy. While the prices might be "devilish," the food is heavenly. This spot is famous for its unique free-range chicken, must-try satay, and a legendary sambal that elevates every bite. Find out if this notoriously quirky restaurant is worth the hype and learn the essential tips for navigating its unusual rules without breaking the bank.
5 Stars on Google, but they won't tell you about the BOGO? This Makassar souvenir shop is playing a different game.
Don't be fooled by the 5-star reviews! While Makassar's Coklatana offers a flawless chocolate cake perfect for souvenirs, there's a catch. This popular shop is known for keeping its buy-one-get-one-free deals a secret from customers. Get the inside scoop on their delicious cakes and learn the essential tips to avoid overpaying and snag a sweet deal on this must-try local treat.
5 RMB per person & a 1-hour queue: What makes this old alley shop so god-tier?
Why are people queuing for an hour down a tiny Makassar alley? For a legendary 5 RMB dish called Songkolo! This 20-year-old spot serves up a flavor-packed black sticky rice with toasted coconut and a secret chili sauce. It's a cheap, delicious, and authentic street food experience. This article reveals the hype behind this "god-tier" eatery and shares essential tips for visiting, from transportation to avoiding common pitfalls.
Why is this 'hole-in-the-wall' the #1 Coto in Makassar?
Discover why a crowded, no-frills "hole-in-the-wall" serves Makassar's #1 Coto. This spot is all about the food, not the ambiance. The secret lies in customizing your own bowl: the initially simple broth transforms into a rich, complex soup after adding salt, lime, and their special sambal tauco. For an incredible price, you get a bowl of tender meat and offal that's so good, it's even attracted presidents. It’s a true taste-over-comfort experience.