4.8 stars on Google, but the service is infuriating? Thanks, I hate this Medan sky restaurant.
qponx
2026-03-06
Thinking of visiting Medan's Penthouse on 19th? This rooftop spot offers a truly stunning city view, but be warned: the service is notoriously bad. This review dives into the highs and lows, from the elegant decor and hit-or-miss food to the infuriating staff and high prices. While the sunset is breathtaking, the experience is a gamble. Find out if the view is worth the frustration and get essential tips before you book your table at this highly-rated but flawed restaurant.
Girls, I just got back from Medan and I have to immediately dish on this super hyped-up rooftop restaurant, Penthouse on 19th. Let me start with the conclusion: The view is truly Mantap, but the service is also truly Anjay… If you're thinking of going for a date, I suggest you read this first before deciding whether to spend your money.
The View from the 19th Floor is Worth Half the Price
To be fair, the view here is undeniably amazing. The moment the elevator doors open, the entire Medan city skyline unfolds before you through the floor-to-ceiling windows. Especially at sunset, the vibes are maxed out[1]. The decor has a high-end, elegant style, perfect for couples on a date or for an anniversary photoshoot, pretending you're on a New York rooftop (not really).
As for the food, it's like opening a blind box. The Salmon Steak Spaghetti[2] I ordered was surprisingly good; the fish fillet was crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, and the flavor was on point. My friend's Garlic Butter Lobster[3] was also decent. But! I've also seen many people complain that their food arrived cold, and some even had a fishy-tasting sea bass spaghetti[4]. So it feels like their quality control is extremely inconsistent; ordering is a total gamble.
Next Up, My Complaints I Just Have to Get Off My Chest
Alright, enough with the praise, let's get to the main point. The service here can really make you experience what it's like to pay to get angry. I read online that the waiters are untrained, have bad attitudes, and even argue with customers[5]. While I didn't have a direct confrontation this time, I definitely experienced the cold shoulder + dismissive attitude the whole time. Plus, the prices are seriously not cheap. A holiday set menu costs 588k++/person[6]. Paired with this kind of service, I can only say the value for money is rock-bottom.
Also, the tables look fancy but wobble at the slightest touch[7]. I was afraid to make any big movements in case I spilled my coffee. The whole experience is held up by the hardware and the view, while the software (the service) is a complete drag.
Guide to Avoiding Pitfalls | A Must-Read Before You Go
If you're going just for the view, remember these few points to make your experience a little better:
- Ask extra questions when booking: I saw someone mention they made a reservation in advance, only to be told upon arrival that they couldn't order food, only drinks[8]. So when you call to book, make sure to confirm again and again that you can dine in!
- Lower your expectations: Just think of it as paying for the view. Don't have any expectations for the service, and you'll reduce your anger level by 80%.
- Time it right: If you don't want to deal with crowds, pick a weekday around 6 PM[9]. There are fewer people, it's quieter, and you can easily get a window seat.
- About the dress code: It's not officially stated, but for a place like this, it's best to dress nicely (Smart Casual). After all, there's an unwritten Dress Code[10], so don't show up in flip-flops and a tank top, okay?
- Stunning 19F city skyline views, best at sunset. The elegant decor gives off major NYC rooftop vibes [1].
- Food's a gamble. Get the Salmon Steak Spaghetti—the salmon is crispy outside, tender inside. The Garlic Butter Lobster is also a safe bet [2].
- Go around 6 PM on a weekday. It's quieter, so you can easily get a window seat for the best Medan views [3].
Similar Articles
This 4.9-star god-tier shop in Medan: Is buying a donut harder than math?
Discover a 4.9-star bakery in Medan that's famous for its heavenly desserts! While its ordering process can be as tricky as a math problem, the food is absolutely worth it. The must-try items are the super fluffy Italian doughnuts (Bomboloni) bursting with generous fillings and the incredibly moist, chewy brownies hailed as the best in town. This guide gives you the inside scoop on what to order and how to navigate the confusing menu for a blissful dessert experience.
Calling all Medan Coffee Heads! I'm scared you'll steal my seat at this floating cabin.
Discover Minum Kopi, a hidden gem tucked away in a Medan back alley. This unique cafe is a wooden house built over a pond, offering a tranquil escape from the city bustle. Sip on high-quality, ethically sourced local coffee at incredibly affordable prices. With its lush green surroundings and chill atmosphere, it's the perfect spot for coffee lovers seeking a peaceful hangout. Just remember to bring mosquito repellent for the full outdoor experience
A 4.7 Google rating? Is this Medan ramen shop for real?
Tempted by a Medan ramen shop's 4.7 Google rating and student-friendly prices? This review dives into whether the hype is real. Spoiler alert: it might not be the goldmine it seems. The author uncovers the truth behind the high score, detailing excruciatingly long waits, undercooked noodles, and a chaotic atmosphere. Discover why this popular spot might be a classic case of "you get what you pay for" and learn some tips to avoid a disappointing experience.
Who says old-school is boring? This Medan Bakmi spot plays harder than you
Discover Haji Mahmud, a legendary 37-year-old Medan bakmi spot with a surprising modern twist. Forget a dated shop; this place boasts a spacious, cafe-bar atmosphere with live music, making it a popular hangout for all ages. While renowned for its "best in Medan" Chicken Mushroom Noodles, it also offers fiery options for spice lovers. This article explores how the old-school favorite stays cool and even reveals a secret to snagging a 50% discount on your meal.