This classic Kemang steakhouse: Is the meat quality a total blind box?
qponx
2026-01-24
Is the legendary El Asador steakhouse in Kemang still worth the hype? This classic spot is famous for its smoky atmosphere, but its reputation is now on the line. While the creamy mashed potatoes and refreshing sangria remain definite highlights, the steak quality has become a total gamble—sometimes juicy and perfect, other times tough and overcooked. This review weighs the pros and cons, helping you decide if this hit-or-miss experience is a risk worth taking for your next meal.
To be honest, every time a friend comes to Jakarta and asks me where to eat steak, the first place that pops into my head is El Asador. This place has been open in Kemang for so many years, it's practically a happy home for a carnivore like me. But recently, its reputation has taken a nosedive, and a lot of old fans have been complaining that the meat isn't good anymore. I thought,"It can't be that bad, right?" I had to come check it out for myself!
Familiar Smoky Vibe, Unfamiliar Steak
The moment I walked in, it was the same familiar vibe: red brick walls with dim lighting, the big grill in the middle burning wood, full of that smoky aroma, creating a great atmosphere for Nongkrong[1]. Sat down and first ordered a glass of Sangria[2], which was still solid; the balance of fruit and alcohol was just right, very refreshing.
Then, of course, the much-hyped Mashed Potato[3]. Ughhh, seriously, it was so creamy, dense, and smooth, so good I wanted to order one to-go! Up to this point, everything was wonderful, until the main event arrived...
We ordered the signature Meat Platter[4]. When the platter was served, it was as impressive as ever, sizzling loudly with an amazing aroma. But... Anjay! I could tell something was off from the first bite. The ribeye steak, which we clearly ordered Medium Rare, turned out to be dry and tough, so chewy my jaw got tired[5]. It completely lacked the tender, juicy texture it used to have. My friend who was with me also had that 'confused old man looking at a smartphone'.jpg expression. It felt like we spent hundreds of thousands just to eat a piece of beef jerky...
So, is it still worth going now?
Honestly, it was a bit disappointing. We even quietly asked the waiter if they had changed owners or chefs, because the quality was so different from before[6]. Although some friends who came recently said it was still pretty good, that the meat quality was Mantap. So now, coming here really feels like opening a blind box; the quality is very inconsistent. If you go expecting"Jakarta's top steak," you'll most likely be disappointed. The value for money has plummeted, and my wallet is feeling the pain.
Editor-in-Chief's Guide to Avoiding Pitfalls 📝
If you still want to try your luck, or are simply craving that mashed potato, save this guide:
- Lower your expectations, focus on the side dishes: The steak is a gamble, but the Mashed Potato[7] and Sangria[8] are almost always a safe bet. Just think of it as a place to come and Chill.
- Ordering tip: The meat is served on a heated platter, so it will continue to cook. If you want Medium, order Medium Rare, and so on, otherwise it will really get overcooked[9]!
- Book in advance: It still gets crowded on weekends, so it's best to book a table in advance via WhatsApp or phone[10].
- Parking is a major headache: There are very few parking spots in the building, and the ramp is as steep as a roller coaster. Be mentally prepared, or just take a Grab. There might also be unofficial parking attendants at the entrance asking for a tip[11].
- The"All-You-Can-Eat" has a time limit: Their All You Can Eat is only available at specific times (e.g., from 5 PM to 6:30 PM), so if you want to take advantage of the deal, don't be late[12]
- The hyped mashed potatoes [1] are divine: creamy, silky smooth, so good you'll want to take some home!
- Former steak king, now quality is a blind box. Signature ribeye was so dry and tough, unchewable [2].
- Red brick, dim lights, big oven: lively Nongkrong vibe [3]. Pair with a fruit-balanced refreshing Sangria [4] for super Chill.
Similar Articles
Calling all Ismaya fans! The vibe at this PIM Kitchenette is seriously Mantap
Discover the Kitchenette at PIM, a standout branch with a unique European street-side bistro vibe perfect for chilling with friends or family. While some dishes can be hit-or-miss, the Mentaiko Pasta and Roasted Chicken are definite must-tries, and you can't leave without tasting the legendary Biscoff Crumble dessert! It’s also a surprisingly great spot for working, offering a comfy alternative to typical cafes. This location's special atmosphere and solid menu make it worth a visit.
I was almost smoked out, but one sip of coffee and I sat right back down.
This South Jakarta cafe is a real mixed bag. While the amazing coffee—especially the Japanese Drip made with beans from their own estate—might just save your soul, a heads-up on the ambiance is needed. A heavy smell of secondhand smoke drifts down from the second floor, impacting the whole space. If you can brave the haze, the delicious panini and friendly staff make it a worthy stop. Otherwise, consider getting your fantastic coffee to-go.
Jakarta's Queue King, Busy Cheese: Original or Black Truffle?
Curious about the long lines at Jakarta's Busy Cheese? This article breaks down the hype, exploring whether its famous cheesecakes are worth the wait. It features a showdown between the silky, semi-molten Original Cheesecake and the polarizing Black Truffle flavor—a unique savory dessert for the adventurous. Plus, get insider tips on the best times to visit to beat the queue, accepted payment methods, and why it's more of a quick stop than a place to hang out.
Mattea, Jakarta's New Hottest Spot: 2-Hour Wait—Social Heaven or Patience Hell?
Jakarta's new hotspot, Mattea, is the talk of the town, but is it worth the hype? This trendy social space boasts a cool industrial vibe perfect for photos and people-watching. While the Nasi Cumi Sambal and Matcha Latte are must-tries, be prepared for a test of patience. The article unpacks the notoriously long waits, inconsistent service, and other pitfalls. Discover if the stylish atmosphere outweighs the chaotic experience before you decide to brave the two-hour queue.